Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts

Saturday, June 15, 2013

Man of Steel Review



There's something inherently fun about Superman, and despite quite a few people dismissing him because of the extent of his power, I have always found him to be incredibly interesting. That's why I've always considered him to be my second favorite superhero behind Spider-Man when people inevitably force me to rank them. Yet, although the early movies are excellent in their own right, they are clearly products of their time and never make it seem like it's awesome to be Superman. And Man of Steel definitely remedies that with ease. But whether or not I consider Man of Steel to be the best Superman movie ever is an argument that I continue to have in my head over 12 hours after leaving the theater. Hit the jump to read my review.

Thursday, May 16, 2013

Star Trek Into Darkness Review

"My name is John Harrison. Seriously. Why is that so hard to believe?"


There is always difficulty in approaching a review of a movie like Star Trek Into Darkness. On the one hand, there quite a bit of information that the filmmakers would like to keep hidden until viewing and on the other hand it's difficult to truly talk about the movie without talking about those hidden moments. So as a result, I am going to try to do my best to talk about the movie without revealing anything that could be considered a spoiler.

Into Darkness takes place not too long after the events of the previous movie. The crew of the Enterprise is out in space, doing what it is they do best. And for the most part that means doing whatever Kirk wants to be doing, regardless of the consequences. So it is during the opening of the movie, when Kirk and crew are attempting to quell an about-to-erupt volcano on the surface of a pre-warp planet. And any Trek fan worth their salt knows that you cannot reveal your existence to any pre-warp civilization as it goes against the Prime Directive. So when the Enterprise must reveal themselves in order to save Spock from the volcano, it causes a little trouble for the crew when they get back to Earth. 

Meanwhile, a mysterious Starfleet Officer named John Harrison (Benedict Cumberbatch) orchestrates a terrorist attack on Starfleet. His intentions remain unknown throughout the vast majority of the movie, but it's clear that he has a bone to pick with Starfleet. Cumberbatch gives an absolutely gripping performance and even if the material wasn't great, and it certainly can be great at times here, he can easily elevate it to a level that would not be capable by many other actors. His motivations are sound, if a little muddled, and his backstory is more abridged than I would have preferred, but that doesn't stop him from being an incredible presence in this movie. (And if you're not already watching "Sherlock", stop reading this right now, fire up Netflix and watch all six episodes.)

This time around, there's no need for the crew to get to know each other, so it's easy to simply jump into the action. The dynamics are there and they haven't skipped a beat in the last four years. The relationship between Uhura (Zoe Saldana) and Spock is still present and it's clear they're experiencing some relational problems. Kirk is as womanizing as ever and Bones is still the cantankerous, metaphor spewing doctor who still isn't given enough screen time. Sure, his role is definitely expanded from the first movie, but I still feel like the Kirk/Spock/McCoy dynamic that was so present in the show and the earlier films is missing in favor of a straight up Kirk/Spock dynamic. Which would be fine if Karl Urban didn't so completely nail a DeForest Kelly imitation while still putting his own unique spin on the role. If there was only one character you could point to as solid follow up to the original cast, I'd have to go with Urban's McCoy. 

But beyond the cast, the film excels by pushing the spectacle while maintaining a solid undercurrent of character development from start to finish, despite some curious missteps along the way and a reliance on too much superficiality. The first odd choice is a change that happens relatively early in the film, which gives the impression that the road to rectify this decision will be a long one. But nope. About 10 minutes after it occurs, the change ends up being reversed. Sure, there are solid reasons as to why this happens but from a story perspective, it's difficult to comprehend and sort of changes the journey of Kirk's character. Because the journey he would have taken under this scenario is much more interesting than the path he ends up taking.

Of course, this is not something that is worth dwelling on since from that point forward the movie moves at breakneck speed. Abrams is a master of introducing high tension even when you know there's no REAL danger at hand. You know certain characters are going to make it through the situation, but that doesn't stop you from moving to the edge of your seat, wondering how they're going to escape. A lesser director would not be able to accomplish such a feat.

The movie also introduces concepts from this new timeline as well as bringing in elements from previous plot lines, including the introduction of Carol Marcus, daughter of Admiral Marcus (and developer of the Genesis device and mother of Kirk's son David in the original timeline). Here played with a British accent, (understandably using Alice Eve's regular accent, but odd considering the original actress Bibi Besch spoke with an American accent as Carol) her presence seems to be little more than fan service to say "Hey, remember Wrath of Khan? That movie was awesome." Other shoutouts seem to do little more than to remind fans of elements of the universe and even one reference to the ill-fated video game I reviewed not too long ago. Did not see that coming.

Which brings me to my next gripe, which is, "What's the point?" I mean, if they were completely reimagining Star Trek, then none of this stuff would bother me. I wouldn't care that Carol Marcus has a different accent or that other changes were made from the original series. At that point it would be its own beast, not too different from the Marvel "Ultimate" line of comics. But by trying to marry it with the original continuity, it simply points out how often it DOESN'T fit with the original continuity. These moments aren't constant, but when they do happen, it really pulls me out of the movie as someone who is a fan of the originals. So if you don't know the previous movies, then these names are irrelevant to you and it doesn't matter who they are. If you are a fan, then the changes can be jarring and alienating to people, so it doesn't really make sense why they're included at all. It simply seems odd to reset the entire universe and then telling the same stories over again.

These sorts of things happen throughout the second act which never seems to fully come together in the way I would have preferred, despite being endlessly entertaining. There just seemed to be a lack of excitement and cohesion that the first movie delivered a lot better during the middle section of the movie.

And one change that occurs about two thirds the way through almost completely pulled me out of the movie all together. I was so focused on this specific change that it became difficult for me to enjoy the movie. That is until a character delivers a speech which has probably one of my favorite non-spoiler lines of all time, "That being said..." When that line is spoken, along with what follows it, I was back on board. I felt like I was given permission to enjoy the movie for what it was.

And from that moment on, everything that happened was so extremely entertaining that I gave up all my previous concerns and just allowed the movie to unfold as it was, despite them going full blast into referencing stories from the history of the franchise. The action was fantastic, the performances were strong, and there were some fantastic call backs to the original timeline which filled my little Trek heart with joy. Especially the musical references. The more that's said about composer Michael Giacchino, the better because he just absolutely knocks it out of the park with this one.

Although I loved the movie completely, there are still elements of concern that I have in the way there seems to be an unwillingness to chart a completely new franchise course which leaves a slightly bitter aftertaste upon further reflection. But taking it on its own, divorced from the history of Star Trek, Into Darkness is a fantastic summer movie. Not the most thought provoking film, but endlessly entertaining with one of the most charismatic ensembles I've seen in a long time. It isn't quite as a cohesive whole as the last movie was, but there are individual moments that are leaps and bounds above what Trek 2009 was able to accomplish. I'd love to see Abrams return for one more outing, but with his Star Wars obligations, I just don't see that happening. But here's to hoping the next adventures do carve out new and unique stories, because the potential with this cast is pretty limitless.

GRADE : A -

Friday, May 3, 2013

Iron Man 3 Review



When a person walks into any sort of franchise movie, there's a level of expectation that exists among those familiar with the previous entries. And often times this expectation can result in a substandard movie as the filmmakers attempt to recreate the magic of before, too afraid to take the movie in too radical direction in fear of alienating the fans who were your prior support. After the runaway success of Avengers, this does not seem to be a fear that Marvel has and never is it more apparent than what transpires in Iron Man 3.

Iron Man 3 is a fascinating movie on so many levels and I applaud Marvel for allowing a filmmaker's voice to be heard so strongly in a franchise movie. The problem is that when taken as a full trilogy, the tone of the third movie is so jarringly different that I can see there being a massive disconnect between the expectations of the audience and what is actually delivered. But I sincerely believe that when taken as an individual entry, it's possible that this eclipses even the first Iron Man, despite some glaring issues.

The movie begins flashing back to New Year's Eve 1999 where we are introduced to Maya Hansen's (Rebecca Hall) Extremis project and a very socially awkward and not too great looking Aldrich Killian (Guy Pearce).  By getting the set up here visually, it definitely frees up what would typically be random exposition throughout the movie and definitely gives the proper context as to who Tony used to be as well as introducing an important plot point that is present throughout the rest of the movie. We then fast forward to a time that's not too long after the events of The Avengers. Tony is having trouble sleeping, working day and night in his workshop building suit after suit after suit to the point where when we catch up to him, he's currently on the Mark 42. Given that the Mark VII was introduced in The Avengers, I'd say he's been a pretty busy guy.

Meanwhile, Rhodey is on the hunt on behalf of the United States government for The Mandarin (Ben Kingsley), an elusive terrorist who is taking credit for several attacks throughout the world. Rebranded with a new paint job and title, Rhodes has dropped the moniker of War Machine and now goes by the Iron Patriot.

To say any more would be to give too much away, but suffice it to say, this is a very interesting movie that has some sizable implications for the movies going forward. Certain liberties are taken with the source material which I suspect is going to rub a lot of fans the wrong way, and although I am personally slightly conflicted about those revelations, I do believe that in the service of this one specific story, they were not the wrong ones. I won't say that they were the right ones, but they definitely serve the story that Shane Black is trying to tell.

Which brings me to Black himself. Tonally, structurally, and hilariously, this movie is pure Shane Black. If you are a fan of Kiss, Kiss, Bang, Bang, and can understand Shane Black's perspective when making this movie, I believe you will be infinitely satisfied. This movie is hysterical in all the right ways while the action set pieces are not only breathtakingly impressive but also service the story in ways many other action movies don't often seem to do. Yet, the thing that must be accepted in order to enjoy this movie is to understand that Black is not Jon Favreau (who still shows up here reprising his role as Happy Hogan, so I'm sure he gave his input when necessary). There's a certain darkness and borderline mean-spiritedness to Black's humor that just isn't in Favreau's wheelhouse. This is not a criticism of either director in any way, just a different stylistic approach and one that resonates with me rather strongly.

Structurally, the movie spends a lot of time relying on Stark's wits and intelligence instead of the brute force nature of his suits. For a significant portion of the film, Tony doesn't use his suit at all. As a result, it often feels less like a "superhero" movie and more like an action/thriller that just happens to have some superheroes in it. Thematically, the trials that Tony goes through fit in perfectly with the adventures that came before. His addiction to the suits is the only thing that allows him to make sense of the world around him, especially after experiencing aliens, gods, and intergalactic wormholes for the first time. Not only that, but he finally understands what it means to love another human being in Pepper Potts and has to weigh the responsibilities of being Iron Man with his concern for her well being. Of course, it's all done in typical Tony Stark/Robert Downey, Jr. fashion, so it never feels overly sentimental.

But the movie does have some negatives. Certain plot points are clear, but completely underdeveloped which makes you wonder why they were included at all other than to reach the end point. The same goes for a few actors who are not utilized to the best of their abilities and when all was said and done was disappointing that they were only there to serve the plot instead of being a fully realized character. Beyond this and the changes from the source material which I'm still on the fence about, there wasn't much to dislike about the movie.

I suppose the final word on this movie is to implore fans of the franchise to take a step back and reset their expectations. This is going to be a different experience. But if you approach it from an understanding that this is a filmmaker bringing his own voice and tone to the project while accepting that this is the next logical step for the development of the character of Tony Stark, then I think it succeeds wildly. All too often, these franchise films stay so committed to the status quo that they never do anything truly interesting. And regardless of your feelings on how it turns out, you certainly can't say that this movie sticks to the status quo. Plus, you know, a legion of different Iron Man suits. Now that's awesome.


GRADE: A- 

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Bioshock Infinite Review



This is not going to be a video game review in the traditional sense. I won't be detailing game mechanics or explaining how fantastic the graphics look unless they relate directly to the story. There are thousands of websites out there who do all that and what my focus is when playing most games is the drive to understand the story, completely spoiler free.

To give a basic summary that does very little to truly outline the complexity of the narrative, in the year 1912, a private eye named Booker DeWitt is hired by mysterious individuals to retrieve a woman named Elizabeth from a floating city called Columbia. Columbia is ruled with a bit of an iron fist by a man named Zachary Comstock. A man who has crafted a city so enamored with the idea of American Exceptionalism that people literally pray to Washington, Jefferson, and Franklin. Memorabilia throughout the city exalts our Founding Fathers as gods with Comstock as their high prophet, through whom all decisions on morality are dictated.

Unfortunately, Comstock's values are a little close-minded as he is open about his feelings on white superiority and everyone who doesn't share this same background is treated quite literally as a second class citizen. Throughout the game, special bathrooms exist for the "blacks and Irish" and are absolutely disgusting in comparison to the "white" bathrooms. And in the very first turning point, Booker is witness to a potential public "stoning" of an interracial couple where people gather and throw baseballs at the unfortunate "offenders". It's there where things really kick into gear as Booker is spoken of as the "false shepherd" that the citizens of Columbia have apparently been preparing for.

From there, Booker meets several people who push him along on his journey to take Elizabeth from the confines of Columbia. But as in all stories like these, there's much more to Elizabeth than is shown at first glance. And as a result, the story goes into many thought provoking and unexpected places that elevate it beyond almost anything I've seen before.

What's fascinating about Bioshock: Infinite is the way that it tackles a number of incredibly heavy concepts throughout its approximately 10-12 hour journey and for the most part treats them with respect and thoughtfulness. Infinite follows a similar pattern as the original Bioshock did back in 2007, but does it in a fresh and exciting way. The ending of Infinite even provided me with a personal sense of understanding as to why sequences unfold as they do. Although that's not to say others would result with the same idea. While the end does certainly provide for definite, if slightly confusing, closure, there are still elements of ambiguity that are open for interpretation.

The biggest downside of the game is how it never really follows through on a lot of these thought provoking plot lines, as the story becomes more focused on the relationship between Booker and Elizabeth towards the end and much of the analytical is dropped for a plot that goes all-in with the metaphysical. I certainly would have enjoyed to see more depth in regards to the racial plot line as well as more exploration into the actual effect that praying to America's Founding Fathers had on the population, but I suppose given that the purpose of the story is to explore these characters it can be overlooked somewhat.

Another downside is the fact that in order to get 100% of the story, you need to search for it. Throughout the game there are 80 audio files and 37 video displays scattered throughout the city which give insight and background to a lot of characters who otherwise wouldn't have received it. At the end of the game, I had only found 60 audio files and 24 video displays so I missed out on 25% of this background information simply because I couldn't find it. I understand that the primary purpose of a video game is not to deliver a story but an interactive experience, but it still grinds the narrative to a dead halt when I'm running in circles trying to find a dumb audio file to help explain what's going on and the main narrative is calling for me to continue forward. It's certainly a jarring experience when in a normal series of events, the main character would look at the "Important Thing" in the distance instead of wandering around looking for money in trash cans or an audio file hidden in a remote corner. Who knows? Maybe the resolution I was looking for in some of those plot threads were contained in the things I could not find.

But the most compelling reason for viewing this story in such high regard is the treatment of the character of Elizabeth. Ken Levine and Irrational Games have shown that a female character in a game can be as complex as in any other media without having to resort to typical low brow tactics. When you first meet her, locked away in her tower, she's a self-taught, strong yet naive woman who just wants to see the world. After escaping the tower into another part of the city, she hears music for the first time and begins to dance in a large group. This whole sequence is done in such a way that you are really able to empathize with her experience and you feel legitimately happy that this character is able to participate when you witness the joy she exudes in that moment. But as the game goes on, this innocence slowly deteriorates as she is continually surrounded by violence. (This is a first person shooter, after all.) The arc from innocent bystander to understanding participant is one that makes perfect sense in the context of the story and never feels forced as the result of some sort of required gameplay mechanic. And not only that, but she is a companion in the true sense of the word. Never do you have to concern yourself with her safety before yours, she takes care of herself, and involves herself in your battles when she can.

That's not to say Booker is a slouch character. Despite very rarely seeing his face, his motivations are consistent and interesting which keeps you consistently involved in what happens to him next. I absolutely hate the silent protagonist in games such as these, so it was a welcome change from the original Bioshock to be controlling someone who actually resembled a fleshed out character, even though he's not quite as rich a character as Elizabeth. (As an aside: I thought the silent protagonist in the original Bioshock was very well done as the twist explained the reason for this quite well.)

The other characters in this game all have interesting perspectives on religion, economics, social classes, and government in their own individual ways, but most are simply serving the story of Booker and Elizabeth and don't have much opportunity to shine. But the fact that this kind of attention to these background characters is present despite the little amount of screen time that they have (if any at all) just further illustrates the brilliance of this game.

I truly wish that more game developers would attempt such thought provoking games because that's the only way to elevate the medium when an attempt is made to put the story front and center.

The scope is incredible and since I've completed it, there hasn't been a day that's gone by that I haven't wanted to jump back into the world of Columbia and experience it all over again.

Grade: A

Saturday, July 21, 2012

The Dark Knight Rises Review

A game of Rock, Paper, Scissors goes horribly wrong leading to a snow covered revolution
I remember talking to people in July of 2008 shortly after The Dark Knight was released and we were talking about sequels. There was a collective agreement that creating a sequel to The Dark Knight was essentially an insurmountable task. That Christopher Nolan had crafted something so fantastic that just the mere thought of something better seemed impossible. In fact, I'm fairly confident I believed that it simply couldn't be done.

As time went on, as more information was revealed about The Dark Knight Rises, I began to start believing. I attempted to keep my expectations in check, but the themes that were seemingly going to be explored, as well as the ever growing talented cast, made it appear that this was going to definitely be one sequel that lived up to the hype.

So now here I am a day removed from seeing for myself, and unfortunately, despite an incredibly solid and entertaining entry, one that feels satisfying as a conclusion, the film just doesn't live up to the bar set by its predecessors. Which is almost an unfair statement to make, given that each film should live as its own animal. But I couldn't help walk out of the theater feeling like something was missing.

I'll keep the plot synopsis short since we've all heard it by now. Eight years after the death of Harvey Dent, Gotham is living in a time of peace. The crime that had once nearly destroyed the city has been all but eradicated. Much of it from a law that was put in lauding Harvey Dent as a hero. The Batman hasn't been seen since, framed for the murders committed by Dent, and a masked man known as Bane is attempting to take over the city. Meanwhile, Bruce Wayne stays confined to his mega-mansion with a bum knee and Selina Kyle does her morally ambiguous thief thing.

The performances were all top notch. Anne Hathaway's Catwoman, who was the only character I was on the fence about, definitely proves herself here. There just seemed to be something off  about her inclusion in all the press materials, but I suppose that's what you get for viewing things like that out of context. Because whenever she is on screen, she definitely steals the show whether through her stunt work or generally playful attitude that the series has been lacking up to this point. Strange that I had these doubts, given that Hathaway has always been a solid addition to any cast. Gary Oldman's tortured Commissioner Gordon looks like the man who has been burdened with the guilt of a soul crushing lie over nearly a decade to the point where his family has left him. Alfred (Michael Caine) and Lucius Fox (Morgan Freeman) are as dependable as ever, barring some extreme circumstances.

The new cast is certainly sufficient if slightly underwhelming. Miranda Tate (Marion Coilitard) is a clean energy investor on the Wayne Enterprises board whose life becomes intertwined with Bruce in an almost jarring start of a relationship. While John Blake (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) shows up as a beat cop who is apparently a master of deduction on par with Sherlock given some of the information he has.

And Bale definitely continues to deliver (save for his kind of ridiculous Batman voice) as the conflicted Bruce Wayne. Wayne continues to torture himself following the loss of Rachel Dawes in the last movie and uses that as an excuse to not move on with his life, allowing Batman to stay out of the limelight until Bane forces Wayne's hand.

The true highlight of the movie though is the one-on-one fight that happens between Bane and Batman about halfway through the movie that has imagery reminiscent of the popular Knightfall arc from the comics back in the 90s. The scene is presented with such brutality, lacking all music and only destructive sound effects. And whenever there is action on screen, Rises is mesmerizing with carefully constructed sequences that truly seem grounded despite the heightened reality. And in IMAX, as the movie is definitely meant to be seen, these sequences are simply jaw-dropping. I wish all directors took IMAX as seriously as Christopher Nolan.

The themes in this movie are rather nebulous, as Bane appears to have a "give back to the people" attitude while simultaneously causing wanton destruction, offering no real solutions to the problem other than just the well-planned terrorist activities that he executes from time to time. Granted, the ending provides ample explanation as to why this is so which ends up deflating Bane's intentions slightly. But prior to this point, the film attempts to be very seriously teeing up a modern day financial allegory that never gets fully explained.

Of course, we also have to deal with Nolan's penchant for momentum stopping exposition. Characters, some of whom inexplicably have what would appear to be very confidential information, will out of nowhere deliver motivation explaining monologues that just seem so inorganic. The information is certainly necessary to understand everything that is going on in a very dense movie, and the actors delivering the lines are fantastic in their own right, but the content is just so blatant that at one point a character literally says "Now this is the important part" when another character is delivering exposition, as if the audience couldn't grasp that fact on their own.

The most unfair criticism I could possibly have is one that I am going to reluctantly take here and that is the lack of Heath Ledger's Joker. The Joker was such a powerful force that his absence in this, as well as the fact that there is not even one mention of him in the entire film, is deeply felt. His perspective among the chaos of Rises would have surely brought the film from very good to obscenely brilliant. Especially a film so determined to take itself so seriously. It's certainly not fair to make that complaint given that it was a literal impossibility for him to reappear in this, but again, when you see how everything else is brought to a natural conclusion, that just feels like a loose end that we're supposed to ignore.

Yet, when all is finished, there is definitely a sense of a completed journey, one that follows a well-defined arc over the course of three films. From a storytelling perspective, and not from a Batman-centric perspective, there is simply no other way for the film to have ended. There is a bittersweet quality to it and a sense that this world will continue beyond what we, the viewers, will experience. While I would definitely love to see more stories told in Nolan's Gotham City, there's a sense of completion that allows me to feel satisfied in a way most other third entries in a series end up. (I'm looking at you, Spider-Man 3.) Few franchises are able to maintain this level of quality, so even if I don't feel that Rises lives up to the levels set by the earlier installments, it's still 10 times more brilliant than most of what passes for blockbuster entertainment these days. I definitely look forward to seeing this one a few more times.

GRADE: B+

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 2 Review

I had written this yesterday morning, but haven't had the opportunity to post it until now. Well, even though everyone has seen this movie already anyway, I figured I'd still share my thoughts.

How can you possibly approach the culmination of a ten year odyssey such as this with anything other than admiration? The mere fact that the Harry Potter series has been able to achieve what it has without any major overhauls is something that's unprecedented in Hollywood. And so it is with that respect that the entire series comes to a close.

The decision to split the final book into two movies was an incredibly smart decision now that the final product has been released. What's even more apparent is just how different the two halves of the book are. While the first half was almost introspective in the way it adhered to the frustrating struggles within the forest, the second bolts right out of the gate offering little time for the slow, almost laborious conversations from the first. Given that the Harry Potter is heavy on exposition, the pace of the second film makes it almost jarring when they stop to explain things. The result is a movie that works as two wholes, each half offering a different type of experience while simultaneously seamlessly connecting as one continuous film.

Obviously by now, most people know the story. And if you don't know the story, well, too bad. Director David Yates has no time to catch you up to speed. You are either a part of this world at this point, or you're not. And frankly, I think the film is all the better for it. Picking up immediately where the first film left off with Voldemort acquiring the Elder Wand while Harry and friends recuperate at the home of Bill and Fleur (and a gravestone that was sorely missing from the first half), Harry soon entrusts the goblin Griphook to break into Bellatrix Lestrange's vault at Gringott's Bank to retrieve the final horcruxes. (I think I just broke my spell check with that last sentence.) The result of which is a thrilling sequence, especially in 3D, through the underground labyrinth of Gingotts that culminates in a daring dragon escape.

One of the more fascinating things about this movie is the way that it's able to deliver things that truly have never been seen before. To visualize in your head a war that is fought almost exclusively by people waving wands at one another sounds silly at best and stupid at worst. Yet, the verisimilitude that Yates brings to the production makes the constant battling an incredible visual experience that is completely sold by the actors' commitment. And even this is to say nothing of the violent destruction and murder present throughout. Watching Voldemort nonchalantly walk through bloodied and mutilated bodies only enhances the fact that there are real stakes in this battle. Long gone are the innocent days of a life-sized chess board or a basilisk who just reversibly freezes people. No, this time people will die. And characters who you would think would be safe in a "children's" series are disposed of with ease.

The caliber of acting on display is also unprecedented. After recently watching some of the earlier films in the series, it's amazing how far the three main characters have come, although Ron and Hermione don't have all that much to do in this final battle other than serve as support and finally embrace their latent feelings for one another. But one person truly shines in this movie and that's definitely Alan Rickman's Severus Snape. His screen time is definitely small, but what he does with it is phenomenal and is easily the standout character of the film. In fact, he may very well be the best character of the entire series and a lesser actor than Rickman could have completely ruined those scenes given that he was expected to do quite a bit in such a condensed amount of time. Even Maggie Smith as Professor McGonnigal is finally given an opportunity to show some fun and adds a sense of wonder that such fantastic British actors have stuck in there (and survived!) throughout this last decade.

But as the series star, the person on whom the entire story relies on, Daniel Radcliffe rises to the challenge of this final chapter and delivers one of his very best performances in the films. Much more naturalistic than in prior installments, his acceptance of his fate showed true growth not only as a character, but as an actor.

Despite the amazing spectacle and the overwhelming emotion of this last installment, there were some minor issues that I'm still unable to tell are actual issues or just my personal complaints about deviations from the book. The first is some of the deaths are visually strange and end up looking more like the flaking away of a vampire more than what other deaths in the series have appeared to be. Secondly, there were clearly a few moments that were just thrown into the movie as fan service to the books with little emotion attached nor the lead up attached. And yet, one of the things that greatly disappointed me was a distinct change from the book that included a tense verbal exchange between Harry and Voldemort during the final battle that was truncated to almost a brief throwaway line.

I often wonder if we'll ever see such a phenomenon again in my lifetime. The way that the Harry Potter saga was able to come together seems like so many things happening in such perfect ways that it almost seems impossible to ever replicate again. Most of the major and best British actors and actresses were able to make appearances in these films to add a layer of even more impossibility to a recreation.

Certainly there were changes from the books I didn't like. And I definitely wish that John Williams would have returned to score the final film, despite Alexandre Desplat doing an admirable job of bringing back many of the themes that Williams had penned so many years ago. But when all is said and done, this was an incredible finale filled with great characters, an amazing visual spectacle, and reverence for the source material that I am certainly glad I was around to witness.


GRADE: A-

-Sean Diroff

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Lost Thoughts 5/11 - Across the Sea


The Deconstruction of the Man in Black

So, that's it people. He has no name. The Man in Black will forever be The Man in Black (or MIB for short), which is something that I'm not particularly happy about. Granted, the overwhelming possibility of names would have ultimately been a let down but I feel like the Man in Black is such a nebulous name that I feel silly even typing it. Which I have done four times already in this one post.

But now we know the history. It may be a history that we were not expecting, and a history some may not even like, but ultimately here it is. And I find myself asking even more questions at times. Who were those other people? Was it a random occurrence they found the island or had they been looking for it in an explorers looking for the Fountain of Youth sense? Precisely what IS the Smoke Monster? These are questions that I'm essentially positive we will not be seeing the answers to. It's absolutely too late in the game to address them at this point, especially because there's no question that we'll be moving at breakneck speeds towards the end of it all after next week.

Casting all those concerns aside for a moment, was this episode entertaining? Was it necessary? And did we learn anything from it? I'd argue yes for the first, maybe for the second, and absolutely for the third.







Lost in Expectations

What this episode presented was an interesting parable about two brothers who, despite being raised the same, end up with completely opposite points of view. Their adoptive mother, a woman tasked with protecting this island at all costs from the danger that lies in the heart of the island, has no trust in humanity. And she clearly sees much of herself in The Man in Black, thus grooming him to be her successor. In fact, in the season 5 finale, MIB uses the exact same phrasing "They come. They fight. They destroy. They corrupt. It always ends the same." They ultimately have the same philosophy. Yet, he had no desire for such a life. Despite his status as the chosen one, MIB is more interested in seeing the world, now knowing his true origins and that a larger world exists. Meanwhile Jacob, who is arguably the better son by acting precisely how his mother wanted, is not given the same respect as his more subversive brother. And Jacob does all of this full well and knowing that his true mother was murdered by this woman who raised him. Yet, despite it all, Jacob is much more optimistic about humanity and their chances. He believes in their inherent goodness as opposed to the pessimism of MIB and Mother.

There was certainly an entertaining quality to the whole episode, watching neither of these characters become true bastions of good or evil. Both of them had a bit of a moral ambiguity that I felt would be not be nearly as prominent after the revelation of last week's episode. There was no question. The Man in Black was a bad man. Here he is just a man who wants to leave a place he was never supposed to be to begin with. His plight is certainly something that can be identified with on a basic level. And Allison Janney did a wonderful job as their rather jaded yet loving mother who apparently just wanted to be set free, as evidenced by her final "Thank you" to MIB after her murder.

The Necessity of the Island's History

There are three and a half hours of the show left. Last week's episode ended on this upswing of momentum that was obviously designed to propel us into the finale. And yet, we take a break from all of that to learn about characters who have literally been behind the scenes for the majority of the series. The result was an episode of Lost that on many levels didn't play as an episode of Lost. Much of the information that was learned could have been gained in conversations between characters. I do applaud the writers for attempting to do something very unconventional here in the last few hours. And I would argue that with a few tweaks this could have been an even better episode than it was, although I think it should have played earlier in the season.

One of my biggest complaints about the earlier episodes of the season was that we just had no idea what the stakes were. We didn't know which side was which or why the game was even being played. The writers said they wanted the audience to be unsure as to whether or not we could trust Locke, but after last week's episode it was clear that he was evil and needed to be stopped. The problem was, we didn't get that pure evil feeling from this week's episode either. This episode could have been placed VERY early in the season and it would have set up quite nicely what was occurring without all the uncertainty. And still, we could have believed that Locke's only goal was to leave the island and experience the world.

Information Overload and Some Rare Speculation

So what was gained by this episode? Well, I will say that I found the revelation of Adam and Eve to be interesting and enjoyable. That was one "question" I didn't feel ever really needed an answer though. I was perfectly content assuming that it was a man and wife who were shipwrecked on the island and died in the cave. Why people gravitated to that question is something that is beyond me, but it goes to show the level of detail many Lost fans expect.

There is a mystical aspect to the show that will never be explained, and that's something I have always expected. The question of where Jacob comes from is answered, but where his adoptive mother comes from will never be, which she addressed in her almost meta-comment when she told the birth mother "Your questions will only lead to more questions." I feel that it's something the audience just has to accept.

The wheel's creation was addressed, but still not fully explained, since Mother went and destroyed the well prior to MIB completing it. There was also a bit of a jump in scientific knowledge regarding mixing water and light and getting off the island. Going from "metal does weird things!" to "turning this wheel by mixing the light and water will create the necessary conditions for leaving the island!" seems to be quite the leap in scientific capabilities. Either way, I'm still unsure to who ultimately ended up finishing the job MIB started.

Now normally I attempt to stay away from speculation, since it's not my strong point. I have been wrong far more often than I'm right, but I feel as if the pieces put in place here will allow me to draw relatively solid conclusions based on the evidence we have been presented with thus far.

Here is the history of the island as I see it. The island has alway been there. Someone has always been there to protect it. The mystical forces at work have always been there. And here's where it gets extremely speculative: The smoke monster, an essence of evil, a harbinger of destruction, has always been there. Trapped within the confines of the "heart" the island. This was information Jacob didn't have. All he knew was that he needed to protect the island from people and protect this light. When he tossed his brother into the light, knowing that it wouldn't kill him, that existing essence merged with the essence of the Man in Black and their mutual desire to leave the island became one. The man, who wanted to see the world, and the monster who wants to destroy it. And in that connection, the monster was released from his holding cell and free to roam the prison of the island using the MIB as a vessel.

EDIT: So upon further reflection, I feel as if that theory is completely wrong. That the light at the heart of the island turned MIB INTO the smoke monster. They are not actually separate entities but one in the same. The power that exists at the heart is shared to an extent with the Man in Black. And therefore if he leaves the island, he takes the heart with him. Which apparently will destroy life as we know it. A bad thing.

Some might argue that the monster is not in fact, The Man in Black, but just going along in that body the same way that he is with John Locke. But to those people I ask why would a monster who is using the body of John Locke invoke the imagery, memory, and emotions of the Man in Black? He talked to Kate sharing the memories of his "crazy person" mother. He said he was once a human. He became incredibly distressed when he saw young Jacob in the jungle. Clearly this thing was once a man, and not just simply using a man as a vessel.

Yet, questions still remain. Questions that will never be answered. How was Jacob able to so easily travel to and from the island in the present? What was MIB's dead mother? Was she a manifestation of the island or a ghost in the Hurley sense of the word? Who finished the Donkey Wheel? And what exactly IS the smoke monster? I posited my own personal belief of what the monster is, but indeed that could turn out to be false.

What They Died for and The End
This was easily my longest Lost post to date, and with good reason. It opened and closed many doors on so many different subjects and elicited a number of different thoughts about the ultimate ending of the show. In 11 short days, it will all be over after the final three and a half hours and I am highly looking forward to it. There were elements of this episode that were mildly disappointing, but as a whole I think it stands up pretty well. The thing is that our collective imaginations are far more capable than those of a few writers in California and when a mystery is presented that takes so long to be resolved but is compelling during the act of the mystery itself, any revelation is probably going to be a let down. Especially when we find ourselves believing even a small element of truth in one moment but when the real truth is revealed, it ends up being completely unrelated. I'm happy with how this episode turned out and in a way it made me more comfortable with accepting things as they are. Mostly I'm happy that we finally understand who these characters are that have been so integral to not only this season, but to the entire series as a whole.